News Reports on State Department Mexico Travel Advisories Lead to Confusion

by Richard D’Ambrosio
News Reports on State Department Mexico Travel Advisories Lead to Confusion

There are no travel restrictions for U.S. government employees (a proxy for advice to tourists) to all of the country’s popular destinations, including resort areas like Cancun. Photo: Shutterstock


Two news website reports and some social media platform posts might lead you to think that the U.S. State Department, in the last week, had updated security advisories for Mexico’s principal tourist destinations. But a State Department official and the Mexico Tourism Board told Travel Market Report that simply isn’t true.

The disparity in what is being reported online, and what has actually occurred, highlights the difficulty that travelers and travel agents can experience when trying to understand the safety and security guidance that official government entities like the State Department are providing. (None of the major national news outlets have reported any changes.)

In Mexico, currently there are no travel restrictions for U.S. government employees (a proxy for advice to tourists) to all of the country’s popular destinations, including resort areas like Cabo San Lucas, Cancun, Cozumel, and Merida.

For example, on the State Department’s Mexico country page, the agency states: “There are no restrictions on U.S. government employees in tourist areas in Chiapas state, such as: Palenque, San Cristobal de las Casas, and Tuxtla Gutierrez.”

Further down, it states: “There are no restrictions on U.S. government employees for stays in the following tourist areas in Jalisco state: Guadalajara, Puerto Vallarta, Chapala, and Ajijic.”

But, according to the State Department official contacted by Travel Market Report, who requested to remain anonymous, these lines “were added on January 10, 2018” to the travel advisory, and have remained unchanged since then.

In both cases, Chiapas and Jalisco states continue to have Level 2 travel advisories, which means travelers should “Exercise Increased Caution.” A Level 1 advisory means “Exercise Normal Precautions,” and Level 3 indicates travelers should “Reconsider Travel.” Level 4 indicates a complete ban on travel to a city or region.

These facts were confirmed by a Mexico Tourism official based in New York City. “Nothing really major has changed in the State Department warning systems from this year,” she said. “Most of the cities within the states are 'proceed with caution.'”

Is the ranking system working?
This kind of confusion was exactly what the State Department was trying to avoid when it launched its new travel advisory ranking system and website earlier this year. Since the beginning of the year, the State Department has assigned a travel advisory level 1-4 to every country, but levels of advice may vary for specific locations or areas within a country. 

For instance, State may advise U.S. citizens to “Exercise increased caution” (Level 2) in a country, but to “Reconsider travel” (Level 3) to a particular area within the country. In most cases, Mexico’s states are ranked at Level 2, though there are no restrictions on cities and resort areas within those states. A handful of states are ranked a level 3 or 4.

Currently, you have to scroll through each Mexican state description, and then typically to the last paragraph below the general state information to find a sentence about popular tourist locations.

Tourism took a hit earlier this year when the U.S. State Department cautioned Americans about visiting Playa del Carmen and other parts of the popular eastern Yucatan coastline, but lifted its warnings within a few weeks. So many travel agents and industry supporters were quick the last week or so to spread the news reports that the State Department travel advisories had somehow changed.

The State Department told Travel Market Report it uses a variety of information to formulate its travel advisories, including crime statistics and other publicly available information, data gathered from U.S. government sources, as well as assessments by embassy and consulate staff. 

Travel advisories “also take into account decisions made to protect the security of U.S. government personnel overseas and ensure that U.S. citizens receive appropriate security information. This analysis is undertaken without regard to bilateral political or economic considerations,” the State Department told Travel Market Report.

The latest State Department update (July 13, 2018) for Mexico was for Ciudad Juarez, where the agency cautioned travelers to increase their safety measures due to a “marked increase in homicides.”

  1
  0
Tip of the Day
The professional travel advisor’s job is to equip the traveler with the necessary information to enable a good decision that will reflect that person’s own risk tolerance.
 
Paul Ruden
Daily Top List

Top Trending Destinations for 2019

1. Italy

2. Paris, France

3. Iceland

4. Bahamas

5. Ireland

Source: T + L

 

TMR THIS WEEK
http://services.travelsavers.com/AMGService.svc/REST/GetImage?ImageID=5c9c49e9-0e02-e911-b9b4-782bcb667b27

Why Travel Makes the Perfect Holiday Gift

Travel advisors are seizing the opportunity to encourage clients to give the gift that can be enjoyed any time of the year.

TMR Recommendations
Top Stories
Will Travel Agents Support Hotels that Support Them?
Will Travel Agents Support Hotels that Support Them?

In light of recent changes to advisor commissions, several lodging companies have spoken up in support of their industry partners.

Luxury Meal Plans Up the Ante at All-Inclusive Resorts
Luxury Meal Plans Up the Ante at All-Inclusive Resorts

It’s not your grandfather’s all-inclusive resort any more, as Hyatt, Hilton, Marriott, Disney and luxury properties add upscale food-and-beverage plans.  

Hertz and CLEAR Partner on 30-Second Car Rental
Hertz and CLEAR Partner on 30-Second Car Rental

A new service promises to get customers out the rental car exit gate using only biometrics, in less than 30 seconds.

Worldview Tours Suddenly Ceases Operations
Worldview Tours Suddenly Ceases Operations

After 40 years of doing business on the up-and-up, it was a shock to those who had worked with the company to see it go under.

What to Know About Navigating Marriott’s Massive Data Breach
What to Know About Navigating Marriott’s Massive Data Breach

Facing extensive costs as a result of the breach, Marriott is offering to pay for customers’ new passports and annual identity monitoring subscriptions.

Anchorage Assesses Damage After Powerful Quake
Anchorage Assesses Damage After Powerful Quake

The scenic Glenn Highway was the hardest hit during the 7.0 magnitude earthquake on Friday.

News Briefs
TMR Report Cards & Outlooks
Advertiser's Voice
Advertiser's Voice: Tauck