Search Travel Market Report

mainlogo
www.travelmarketreport.com
  • News
  • Packaged Travel
  • Cruise
  • Hotels & Resorts
  • Destinations
  • Retail Strategies
  • Niche & Luxury
  • Air
  • Training & Resources
  • Who We Are
    • Brian Israel
    • Briana Bonfiglio
    • Dan McCarthy
    • Dori Saltzman
    • Jennifer Arango
    • Kelly Fontenelle
    • Keri-Anne Slevin
    • Louis Intreglia
    • Tom McCarthy
Sponsored By ALG
Sponsored By ALG

New Legislation to Eliminate the Airlines’ Liability Shield

by Paul Ruden / October 07, 2022
 American Economic Liberties Project Paul Ruden

Photo:  Martin Chavez / Shutterstock.com

The American Economic Liberties Project has announced new legislation to address the issues created by federal preemption of state law and the related lack of a private right of legal action in the original Airline Deregulation Act of 1978. 

The AELP is a non-profit, non-partisan project – essentially a think-tank – working to “combat monopolistic corporations and the systems that entrench their power.”

The legislation was drafted by William J. McGee, Senior Fellow for Aviation and Travel, and Lee Hepner, Legal Counsel for AELP. It follows the issuance of a letter from the National Association of Attorneys General, in which 38 state attorneys general proposed that Congress allow them to enforce state and federal consumer protections for airline passengers.

You may recall that in 1992 the U.S. Supreme Court held that the Airline Deregulation Act preempted enforcement against the airlines of the NAAG fare advertising guidelines. Morales v. Trans World Airlines, Inc., 504 U.S. 374, 378 (1992). Many other court cases have followed as the courts struggled to draw distinctions about the meaning of “related to a price, route, or service of an air carrier,” the statutory phrase that delineated what was preempted.

The language used by Congress was vague and left open to judicial determination a broad range of subjects that would, taken together, leave the airlines free of meaningful discipline by state laws designed to protect consumers. The net result was that the Department of Transportation was left as the sole arbiter of airline consumer protection. It’s fair to say, I believe, that prior to the pandemic and the conflict over refunds due travelers for airline-canceled flights, DOT’s consumer protection performance was uneven at best. In the pandemic-driven context, it was, and remains, abysmal. Billions of dollars in refunds, clearly owed are still outstanding as 2022 draws to a close.

The NAAG proposal would authorize the state AGs to enforce their consumer protection laws against the airlines. It would shift authority for federal enforcement from DOT to either the Department of Justice or the Federal Trade Commission. AELP’s proposal is even more comprehensive. It authorizes private “rights of action,” (the right to sue airlines directly for alleged wrongs), prohibits ownership of multiple airline interests by Wall Street investment groups, and permits state AGs, courts, and legislatures to regulate and enforce to protect consumer rights. The proposed law is endorsed by the Business Travel Coalition, Consumer Action, the Consumer Federation of America, Ed on Travel, the National Consumers League, Public Citizen, the Public Interest Research Group, and the Revolving Door Project at the Center for Economic Policy and Research.

I am not aware of any other industry that enjoys what AELP accurately calls the “airlines’ liability shield.” Certainly, the travel advisor industry has no such protection. Indeed, as you have hopefully read in prior columns, advisors are frequently treated as fiduciaries in relation to their customers, a vastly greater standard than applies to the airlines.

The goal of the Airline Deregulation Act’s preemption provision was to prevent the states from inserting their own comprehensive regulatory systems in lieu of the federal one that Congress was abandoning. The result of the language chosen has been disastrous for consumer interests. DOT’s episodic and complex efforts to adopt pro-consumer regulations take years to achieve and often fall short of their asserted goals. As we saw with the undoing of the predecessor rulemaking to the pending proceeding on airline refunds, political interference can also stymy effective action. AELP is correct that structural change in the statutory scheme is essential to remedy the vacuum that exists in the protection of air travel consumers.

The AELP move is clearly very impactful. For that reason, it will almost certainly face strong opposition from the airline industry. For the same reason, support from travel advisors will be very important as the legislative process unfolds. The text of the proposed legislation can be read here.

  23
  0
Related Articles
The Battle Against Junk Fees: Big Business Defends Deceptive Practices
Governmental Rules and More Rules: What's an Advisor to Do? Part 4
The Travel Industry Is One Step Closer to the End of Junk Fees
Governmental Rules and More Rules: What's An Advisor to Do? Part 3
How and Why Your TSA PreCheck Application Could Be Rejected
Governmental Rules and More Rules: What's An Advisor to Do? Part 2
What Is Skiplagging and Why Advisors Should Know About It
Hope Springs Eternal with New DOT Rulemaking
The Use Cases for Artificial Intelligence in the Travel Industry
Is ChatGPT a Friend or Foe to Travel Agents? Part 2

MOST VIEWED

  1. The Best Black Friday and Cyber Monday Travel Deals for 2023
  2. The Ten 'Most Christmassy' Towns in the U.S.
  3. Brazil Launches Electronic Visa Platform for U.S. and Canadian Travelers
  4. Venice Gondola Capsizes After Tourists Ignore Driver Instructions
  5. What Will Be the Biggest Travel Trends of 2024?
  6. The Worst Airports for Holiday Flight Delays


  1. Here Are the New Cruise Ships Debuting in 2024
  2. Royal Caribbean Monitoring Haiti Violence
  3. Iceland Travel Update: Southwest Earthquakes Heighten Risk of Volcanic Activity
  4. 15 Exciting New Hotels Opening in 2024
  5. The World's Most Expensive Flights
  6. CBD Gummies Result in Lifetime Passenger Ban for Carnival Cruiser
TMR Subscription

Subscribe today to receive daily in-depth coverage, analysis of industry news, trends and issues that affect how you do business. Subscribe now for free.

Subscribe to TMR

Top Stories
The Top 10 Travel Gear Gifts for This Holiday Season
The Top 10 Travel Gear Gifts for This Holiday Season

Ten products that make great gifts for clients or for the travelers in your life. 

Air and Train Travel Still Impacted by Snow in Southern Germany
Air and Train Travel Still Impacted by Snow in Southern Germany

Flights are slowly resuming at Munich Airport.

Alaska Airlines to Acquire Hawaiian Airlines for $1.9 Billion
Alaska Airlines to Acquire Hawaiian Airlines for $1.9 Billion

The deal still needs to be approved by regulatory boards and Hawaiian Holdings shareholders.

Canada Updates Ireland Travel Advisory After Dublin Riots
Canada Updates Ireland Travel Advisory After Dublin Riots

The riots took place on Nov. 23. 

TSA Breaks Record on Sunday After Thanksgiving
TSA Breaks Record on Sunday After Thanksgiving

The agency screened more than 2.9 million passengers on Sunday.

Iceland Travel Update: Flight Operations Normal Amidst Volcanic Caution
Iceland Travel Update: Flight Operations Normal Amidst Volcanic Caution

As more time passes, the likelihood of an “imminent” eruption decreases.

OUTLOOKS & WHITE PAPERS
Trends in River Cruise, 2023
European Travel Trends 2023
Winning in The Tech Era: Essential Insights for Travel Advisors
View All
Advertiser's Voice
tmrtv.jpg
https://img.youtube.com/vi/VV869UVCj4o/0.jpg
Video: What Makes a Good Travel Advisor?
About Travel Market Report Mission Staff Advisory Board Advertise
TMR Resources Webinars Calendar of Events Outlook/Whitepapers Previous Sponsored Articles Previous This Week Articles
Subscribe to TMR
Select Language
Do You Have an Idea Email
editor@travelmarketreport.com
Give Us a Call
1-(516) 730-3097
Drop Us a Note
Travel Market Report
71 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
News |Packaged Travel |Cruise |Hotels & Resorts |Destinations |Retail Strategies |Niche & Luxury |Air |Training & Resources |Who We Are
© 2005 - 2023 Travel Market Report, an American Marketing Group Inc. Company All Rights Reserved | 243 South Street, Oyster Bay, NY, 11771 USA | Telephone (516) 730-3097| Terms and Conditions
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy