Should the Cruise Industry Rethink Megaships?
by Maria Lenhart

The Carnival Triumph fiasco provided a textbook case of the logistical problems that megaships are likely to encounter during a crisis. Inevitably, this raises the question – should the cruise industry be rethinking the trend toward bigger and bigger ships?  

What, if anything, do last week’s events, in which an engine room fire caused the Triumph to drive without power for five days, say about the contingency plans that cruise lines should have in place, no matter what size the ship?

For a perspective on these issues and others, Travel Market Report spoke with cruise industry expert Dr. Andrew Coggins, a professor of tourism management at Pace University in New York. A retired U.S. Navy Commander, Coggins is a frequent speaker at cruise industry conferences.

What created the operating problems for the Carnival Triumph – and could it happen on other cruise ships?
Coggins: Ships today are almost entirely dependent upon electricity, so when you lose electricity, you lose everything. Except for emergency generators that can operate things like lights in the corridor, there’s nothing [else] to power refrigeration, air conditioning and the sewage system.

With pollution regulations, the whole sanitary system goes through an onboard treatment plant powered by electricity, as opposed to 30 years ago when everything was dumped over the side. So in the old days, the ship would still have had its toilets working during a power failure.

Is a problem like a power shutdown worse for passengers on a megaship than on a smaller one?
Coggins: When something like this happens, the big issue is managing the people. With a smaller ship, this is easier.

As the size of ships has grown, they’ve added more staterooms and deck levels, but not more public deck space. The idea is that with so many staterooms having verandas, people will not need as much public deck space.

However, this becomes a real problem when people can’t stay in their cabins [because of unsanitary conditions]. Where do you put them all? The cruise lines need to have a contingency plan for how they manage people in a crisis like this.

Will the cruise industry rethink megaships? Should it?
Coggins: It’s unlikely that it will. It’s the megaships that have made cruising affordable for so many people. They provide the economies of scale that keep costs down.

And many people, including the first-time cruisers that the industry is trying to attract, are drawn to all the onboard activities. They think they might be bored on the ship.

Will the Carnival disaster put a damper on overall cruise sales?
Coggins: There will probably be a short-term impact. We’re in the middle of Wave Season so we won’t really know for a couple of weeks. I think Carnival itself will take a short-term dip, but I don’t know that there will be much collateral damage to other lines – including those that are operated by Carnival Corp.

What is your long-term forecast for the cruise industry? Will consumer interest continue to grow?
Coggins: Yes, I see interest continuing to grow, especially in consumer markets like South America and Asia, which has a rising middle class. The global market for cruises is big. This is why CLIA has taken on more of a global focus.

What’s your advice for travel sellers if clients express concerns about cruising?
Coggins: I would tell them that incidents like this are extremely rare. In fact, I can’t think of another one like this. The cruise industry is far from unsafe. People can still go and have a good time.

  0
  0
Comment:
You must be logged in to leave a comment Login | Register
Comments
Eileen    2/28/2013 4:21:55 PM
What would be the purpose of life boats if they don't work without electricity?   Eileen 

0
Ann    5/6/2013 6:51:18 PM
Dr. Coggins states he can't think of any other cruise ship disasters. I can think of the Carnival Splendor last year, and the Costa Concordia....

0
Tip of the Day

We stopped taking the bargain hunters and focused on the complex FITs and river cruises. It happened naturally; the business you take is the business you make, I believe. When we learned to say no to what we didn't want, our requests turned into the kind we were saying yes to every time.

Heather Christopher
Travel Consulting

Daily Top List

Best Last-Minute Memorial Day Getaways

1. Atlanta

2. Napa and Sonoma, California

3. New Orleans

4. Miami and Fort Lauderdale

5. Louisville, Kentucky

6. Washington, D.C.

Source: Condé Nast Traveler

Top Stories
EgyptAir Plane Goes Missing Midair
EgyptAir Plane Goes Missing Midair

Flight 804 was traveling from Paris to Cairo when it disappeared from radar over the Mediterranean Sea.

Where U.S. Travelers Plan To Visit This Year
Where U.S. Travelers Plan To Visit This Year

A new survey shows Europe still tops the list.

Senators Say Carry-Ons Are Clogging Security Lines
Senators Say Carry-Ons Are Clogging Security Lines

As DHS asks for traveler patience, two senators call out the airlines, saying checked baggage fees are to blame.

Favorable Currency Exchange And Low Gas Prices Boost Québec Summer Bookings
Favorable Currency Exchange And Low Gas Prices Boost Québec Summer Bookings

“This will be a record breaking year for us. All the stars are aligned,” says Robert Mercure, General Manager, the Fairmont Le Chateau Frontenac.

Passport Renewals Still On Track For Four-Week Turnaround
Passport Renewals Still On Track For Four-Week Turnaround

But “what we see every Monday morning are people who missed their flights on the weekend because they were denied, and now they need expedited paperwork.”

Marriott/Starwood Merger Hits Another Snag
Marriott/Starwood Merger Hits Another Snag

Two Starwood hotel owners have sued to stop the proceedings. 

News Briefs
Advertiser's Voice
Travel Market Report Spotlight: Celebrity Cocktails