Search Travel Market Report

mainlogo
www.travelmarketreport.com
  • News
  • Tours & Packages
  • Cruise
  • Hotels & Resorts
  • Destinations
  • Retail Strategies
  • Niche & Luxury
  • Well-Being Travel
  • Training & Events
  • Who We Are
    • Anne Marie Moebes
    • Brian Israel
    • Dan McCarthy
    • Denise Caiazzo
    • Marilee Crocker
    • Paul M. Ruden
    • Dori Saltzman
    • Kelly Fontenelle
Allianz

Supplier ‘Come Back’ Programs Raise Ire of Destination Wedding Specialists

by Richard D’Ambrosio / November 14, 2018
Supplier ‘Come Back’ Programs Raise Ire of Destination Wedding Specialists

Destination wedding specialists share their dissatisfaction with supplier programs that encourage guests to steer future bookings away from their agent. Photo: Shutterstock


Calling the practice “stealing” and “backstabbing,” and expressing their sense of “betrayal,” travel advisors are registering their dissatisfaction and concern with suppliers that make special offers directly to an agency’s clients to win direct future bookings.

Nine out of ten advisors who responded to a survey conducted this month by the Destination Wedding & Honeymoon Specialists Association (DWHSA), said they want suppliers to stop offering these special “Come Back” deals and discounts.

It has been a common practice for some resorts to offer special deals and discounts to guests at check out, or to obtain the guest’s contact information to send them direct offers after they return home.

If suppliers insist on maintaining these programs, 93 percent of advisors believe they should be credited automatically for future bookings and nearly 88 percent said they should receive full commission for those sales. Some 11 percent said they would accept partial commissions. More than 360 advisors responded to the DWHSA survey.

"As travel advisors, we believe strongly that our clients belong to us," said Lisa Sheldon, DWHSA's president and the owner of I Do Island Weddings in Janesville, Wisconsin. "We book our clients as guests with suppliers — we're not sharing those clients. And, as the survey results show, we don't need the help of suppliers to follow up with our own clients.

Related Articles

American Queen Moves into Great Lakes, Acquires Victory Cruise Lines
 

"We've done the hard work and shouldered the expense of turning consumers into clients," she said. "It's unfair — and unethical — for suppliers to take our clients' information, talk them into future bookings at rates we can't always match as agents, and reap the profit from those sales."

John Hawks, DWHSA administrator, cited the major cruise lines as a model for better collaboration. "If our clients book future voyages onboard the ship, many cruise lines credit the agent of record automatically and pay commission on those bookings — no forms, no hoops to jump through, just a mutually beneficial and respectful relationship."

One agent, responding through the survey’s open-ended questions, agreed with Hawks, saying “Cruise lines do a good job when it comes to crediting,” but feels resorts and hotels “are trying to squeeze us out any way they can.”

DWHSA didn’t ask questions about whether or not the issue has increased recently, but one respondent to the survey felt that it is a growing trend, especially with resorts that have time share units, including “higher end properties.”

“Many of my guests … have been harassed even after they say no the first time,” the advisor wrote. “So, the push has been stronger this year to convert to non-agent. I warn my clients that it will happen while they are there.”

In one instance cited by a survey respondent, a supplier described to a guest how their agent used previous stay credits “to make what I offered on the current booking look better,” and told the client “they can only get this price by booking on property through them. It makes the client have doubts about me and I am the one that sent them … in the first place.”

DWHSA has not called for a boycott of any suppliers, but some of its members, in their responses to the open-ended survey questions, said they are effectively doing that individually.

“I have moved business for my most loyal clients AWAY from suppliers that do not automatically credit me OR decrease commission on these types of bookings,” one agent told the DWHSA.

With one resort contacting clients post-trip, and allowing agents to “take over” future bookings only with the client’s permission, “these are resorts that I sell limitedly,” the agent wrote.

Said another: “I am less likely to offer resorts and brands that harass clients on property for timeshares and/or reach out to my clients after travel with offers I cannot match.”

Searching for a middle ground
It’s not certain where DWHSA will take their members’ comments and concerns next. It has been speaking with suppliers whom members have expressed concerns about, the organization said.

Some of DWHSA’s members are willing to compromise on an equitable split, while others refuse to give any ground. “I deserve full commission on these bookings,” one agent said. “They’re my clients. I sent them.”

One agent considered a precedent of less than full commission “a slippery slope.”

Others were willing to compromise. One agent offered the concept of an 80/20 split, where the agent receives 80 percent of a normal agent-only booking. Another said, “I would be OK with a minor 2-3 percent reduction in commission, but not a commission of 10 percent or lower.”

“It would be much more of a team approach if the vendor would tell the agent of any specials/promotions that might be offered to our client. Then the agent can follow up and demonstrate to the client the power of our agent partnership with the resort/travel vendor,” offered one survey respondent.

A sense of betrayal and lack of respect
The many issues that agents have with these programs could be seen in more of the open-ended responses. One agent noted how they felt advisors weren’t being respected for all of the consultative selling they perform.

“My service involves account management, service and advocacy for my clients. It is more than booking a flight and a room,” one wrote.

A strong sense of betrayal fills the comments provided by agents, with one agent calling the practice “rude.” “It shouldn’t happen ever,” another agent said, adding that “they need to respect the role we play in filling their resorts!”

Another agent likened the tactics to “friend stealing.” They told DWHSA: “I introduced my client to their product, not the other way around.”

Respondents also noted that direct offers often damage a client’s relationship with the resort and the agent, because the customer fully expects the two parties to work together to provide superior customer service for the entire trip.

“I have had that experience two times in 10 years, when clients contacted me after they booked through the resort. Both thought I knew and were expecting my awesome customer service experience. Which they did not receive,” the agent wrote.

As a result, Come Back programs undermine the profession because they send a message to consumers that a travel professional only facilitates transactions, versus being an adviser and service provider. “It distorts the agent/client relationship, giving the clients the image they don’t need the agent to book that particular supplier,” said one agent.

Interestingly, 7.4 percent of respondents said they “have no problem” with supplier Come Back programs, while 2 percent said they don’t feel strongly one way or the other.

“I wish they wouldn’t, but in the end, they’re in this business to make money,” wrote one agent. “There are some agents that don’t follow up well with their clients and our suppliers know that. It’s hard to fault them for seeing an opportunity and capitalizing on it.”

“I don’t mind the suppliers offering specials while my clients are onboard or on property,” wrote another. “That is the best time for clients to rebook while they are ‘in the glow’ of a great vacation. I always encourage clients to take advantage of that but let me know when they get back so I can service them afterwards.”

The survey was conducted online Nov. 8-11, 2019, from a database of 5,520 U.S. and Canadian DWHSA member agents, those who have participated in past DWHSA classes and events, or who have had other contacts with DWHSA. The organization said the survey has a 95 percent confidence level, with a margin of error of 5 percent.

  6
  0
Allianz
Related Articles
Interest in European Destination Weddings is Growing
New York City and Cancun Rank as Top Valentine’s Day Hot Spots
10 of the Most Romantic Destinations Around the World
Ditch the Destination Wedding Hard Sell, and Be Yourself to Increase Sales
Destination Wedding Couples Are Happier
What One Bride Learned From Planning Her Own Destination Wedding
Social Media Raises the Bar for Destination Wedding Specialists
Hawaii Tops For Romance In U.S. News Rankings
Cayman Islands Expand Destination Wedding Marketing
Direct Communications Enable The 24/7 Travel Agent

MOST VIEWED

Brought To You By
  1. A&K Purchases Crystal Ships, Revives Crystal Cruises Brand
  2. CDC Adds Three Caribbean Destinations to “High-Risk” COVID-19 List
  3. Travel to Italy Is Officially Back to Normal
  4. Viking Drops Onboard & Pre-Cruise COVID-19 Testing
  5. Three Cruise Lines Bring Masks Back in Alaska
  6. Travel Advisors Continue Push for Removal of U.S.’s Inbound Testing Requirement

MOST EMAILED

Brought To You By
  1. Travel to Italy Is Officially Back to Normal
  2. Report: U.S. to End COVID-19 Air Travel Testing Requirement
  3. A&K Purchases Crystal Ships, Revives Crystal Cruises Brand
  4. Japan Could Boot Tourists Who Disobey COVID-19 Rules
  5. Viking Drops Onboard & Pre-Cruise COVID-19 Testing
  6. Bahamas Eliminates Travel Health Visa, But COVID Test Requirement Remains
Allianz
TMR Subscription

Subscribe today to receive daily in-depth coverage, analysis of industry news, trends and issues that affect how you do business. Subscribe now for free.

Subscribe to TMR

TMR Recommendations
Daniel Zim
Zim Travel Law, PLLC. Demystifying Complexity with Down to Earth Advice. Attorney Advertising.
hbar
Rodney Gould
Rodney E. Gould concentrates in travel and tour-operator litigation and regularly counsels travel-related entities worldwide.
hbar
Tom Carpenter
Carpenter Law Office - Representing clients in the travel and tourism industries. Attorney Advertising.
hbar
Top Stories
Staffing Remains the Biggest Issue for the Travel Industry
Staffing Remains the Biggest Issue for the Travel Industry

Almost every single service sector worldwide is struggling with staffing issues and the travel industry is no exception.

Read...
Marketing, Engagement, & Partnerships Lead Discussions as TMP East Opens
Marketing, Engagement, & Partnerships Lead Discussions as TMP East Opens

The two-day conference provides attendees a packed schedule of general sessions, TED-style talks, panel discussions, a packed trade show floor and more.

Read...
U.S. Travel Association Names Roger Dow’s Successor in Geoff Freeman
U.S. Travel Association Names Roger Dow’s Successor in Geoff Freeman

Freeman will take the reins on Sept 1, taking over for Dow who is wrapping up a 17-year tenure as U.S. Travel’s leader. 

Read...
Legislative Day 2022: Two Big Priorities for ASTA’s ‘Most Significant Day’
Legislative Day 2022: Two Big Priorities for ASTA’s ‘Most Significant Day’

More than 230 travel advisors from 47 states came to D.C. for this year’s Legislative Day, just three states shy of its 50-state goal. 

Read...
What to Know About Shipping Luggage Ahead of Travel
What to Know About Shipping Luggage Ahead of Travel

Shipping luggage is safe and reliable, but there are some things to avoid. 

Read...
Despite Inflation and Rising Costs, Travel Is Still Top-of-Mind for U.S. Consumers
Despite Inflation and Rising Costs, Travel Is Still Top-of-Mind for U.S. Consumers

New survey data from ASTA saw that consumers are still preparing to travel despite the rising cost. 

Read...
TMR OUTLOOKS & WHITE PAPERS
CP White Paper
Multi-Gen Outlook
Distribution Outlook (1)
New to Cruise Outlook
Expedition 2020
River Cruise Outlook 2019
View All
Advertiser's Voice
https://img.youtube.com/vi/QTPIinGDcIY/0.jpg
Video: Can Booking Bachelor and Bachelorette Party Groups Be Profitable for Advisors?
About Travel Market Report Mission Editorial Staff Advisory Board Advertise
TMR Resources Webinars Calendar of Events
Subscribe to TMR
Select Language
Do You Have an Idea Email
editor@travelmarketreport.com
Give Us a Call
1-(516) 730-3097
Drop Us a Note
Travel Market Report
71 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
News|Leisure Travel|Land Vacations|Cruise|Canada Retail Strategies|Well-Being|Luxury|Training
© 2005 - 2022 Travel Market Report, an American Marketing Group Inc. Company All Rights Reserved | 243 South Street, Oyster Bay, NY, 11771 USA | Telephone (516) 730-3097| Terms and Conditions
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy