Search Travel Market Report

mainlogo
Subscribe to TMR
U.S.A.
English
Canada
English
Canada Quebec
Français
  • News
  • Tours & Packages
  • Cruise
  • Hotels & Resorts
  • Destinations
  • Retail Strategies
  • Air
  • River Cruise
  • Training & Resources

Travelers May Have No Legal Recourse for ‘Abusive’ Screenings

by Richard D’Ambrosio  July 18, 2018
Travelers May Have No Legal Recourse for ‘Abusive’ Screenings

According to the ruling, Transportation Security Administration (TSA) screeners are immune from abuse claims by travelers who feel they have had overly invasive searches performed on them. Photo: J.L.B / Shutterstock.com

A U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Transportation Security Administration (TSA) screeners are immune from abuse claims by travelers who feel they have had overly invasive searches performed on them.

In a 2-1 vote last Wednesday, the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia rejected the claims of business consultant Nadine Pellegrino, who filed a lawsuit in 2009, after an incident at Philadelphia International Airport in 2006. That suit was rejected by a District Court and Pellegrino appealed.

TSA screeners are not “investigative or law enforcement officers,” the District Court ruled this week, upholding TSA employee protections under the U.S. government’s sovereign immunity provisions. As a result, the Circuit Court affirmed the District Court’s judgment dismissing her lawsuit.

Despite the ruling, Circuit Judge Cheryl Ann Krause wrote that: “We are sympathetic to the concerns this may raise as a matter of policy, particularly given the nature and frequency of TSOs’ contact with the flying public. For most people, TSA screenings are an unavoidable feature of flying … and they may involve thorough searches of not only the belongings of passengers but also their physical persons — searches that are even more rigorous and intimate for individuals who happen to be selected for physical pat-downs after passing through a metal detector or imaging scanner,” Krause wrote.

“For these reasons, Congress may well see fit to expand the proviso or otherwise legislate recourse for passengers who seek to assert intentional tort claims against TSOs,” Krause wrote on behalf of the majority opinion.

This was the first such federal appeals decision on whether a waiver of immunity for investigative and law enforcement officers extended to screeners.

According to court filings, Pellegrino, 57, had been randomly selected for additional screening at the Philadelphia airport before boarding a US Airways flight to Fort Lauderdale, Florida.

When Pellegrino objected to the levels of further screenings, police were called in and she was arrested and eventually jailed for about 18 hours and criminally charged. She was acquitted at a March 2008 trial.

  
  
Related Articles
TSA Now Lets You Go Through Airport Security Without a Flight Ticket at 13 Airports
Three More U.S. Airports Opt to Privatize their Airport Security
Google Wallet Becomes First Digital Wallet to Direct-Enroll TSA PreCheck Touchless ID
TSA Unveils Gold+ Program in Major Shift Toward Private Airport Security
TSA Officers Could Go Back to Being Unpaid in May
TSA Pay Update: Relief Arrives Today, But Shutdown Standoff Continues
Senate Passes TSA Funding to End Standoff, Major Airports Still Face Heavy Friday Delays
TSA Wait Times Extend to Two Hours in More Airports as Shutdown Hits Week 5
TSA Absences Could Force Shutdown of Some Smaller Regional Airports
Bad Weather and Long TSA Security Waits Hit Spring Break Travel
TMR Subscription

Subscribe today to receive daily in-depth coverage from all corners of the travel industry, from industry happenings to new cruise ships, hotel openings, tour updates, and much more.

Subscribe to TMR

Top Stories
Tanzania to Require Mandatory Local Travel Insurance Starting Oct. 1
Tanzania to Require Mandatory Local Travel Insurance Starting Oct. 1

The specific policy depends on how a tourist is entering the country.

Palma de Mallorca Sets Cruise Ship & Passenger Number Limits
Palma de Mallorca Sets Cruise Ship & Passenger Number Limits

Under the agreement, daily cruise passenger numbers will be reduced from 8.500 to 7,500.

Visit Florida Keys & Key West Appoints New CMO
Visit Florida Keys & Key West Appoints New CMO

Daniel Cuellar previously directed marketing campaigns for Qantas Airways, United Airlines, and the NFL.

Dominica Launches New Online Training Course for Travel Advisors
Dominica Launches New Online Training Course for Travel Advisors

The Caribbean destination’s Online Travel Training course is now available for advisors to complete.

The Best Las Vegas Tribute Shows to See Right Now
The Best Las Vegas Tribute Shows to See Right Now

Three don’t-miss productions are currently playing in the city. 

Former African Travel Inc. President Sherwin Banda Launches Africa Tour Operator
Former African Travel Inc. President Sherwin Banda Launches Africa Tour Operator

The advisor-first model includes commissions of up to 15%, with commissions paid in the month of client departure.

Outlooks

View All Outlooks ›

White Papers

View All White Papers ›

Destination Guides

View All Destination Guides ›
industry spotlight
https://img.youtube.com/vi/UF_PlocVJTo/0.jpg
How Villas of Distinction Helps Advisors Deliver More Than Just a Villa
Advertiser's Voice
Make It All Feel New Again at Couples Resorts
About Travel Market Report Mission Meet the Team Advertise Syndication Guidelines
TMR Resources Calendar of Events Outlook/Whitepapers Previous Sponsored Articles Previous This Week Articles
Subscribe to TMR
Select Language
Do You Have an Idea Email
editor@travelmarketreport.com
Give Us a Call
1-(516) 730-3097
Drop Us a Note
Travel Market Report
71 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
© 2005 - 2026 Travel Market Report, an American Marketing Group Inc. Company All Rights Reserved | Terms and Conditions
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Manage cookie preferences